One of my favorite parts of the recent town hall with Hillary and Bernie was when they were asked to frame their ‘spiritual’ perspectives on the world. Paraphrasing, Bernie said whatever happens to the least of us, happens to us all – that injustice has always moved him deeply. And Hillary said she practices being grateful – she returns again and again to a place of gratitude.
While both of these are critical components of compassionate humanity and, I think, essential to a spiritual practice, here again we see a gentle, nuanced contrast between candidates – both are honest and lovely responses. But which of those answers resonated with you?
In my own life, gratitude saves me every day. But that’s now. I crawled my way toward gratefulness one hard knock at a time. There were many years when I was so broken down, I could not have even understood the concept of gratefulness, though surely, had I been able to, it would have helped. It would have been a very effective solution. But honestly, when I was really lost and down and out, if someone had suggested gratitude, it would have fallen on deaf ears. Worse, it may have alienated me further from the world. It would have been the right solution offered at the wrong time.
When people are hungry, and beaten, and incarcerated unjustly; when discriminated against and brutalized by war, addiction, abuse, violence, poverty or mental illness; gratitude seems like step 2. Like the thing you do after someone saves your life, or you save your own. Or maybe you say thank you, as a practice, but can’t really feel gratitude until much later. Maybe being grateful is something that happens when we have the ability or capacity to receive grace – when one has experienced a place of being ‘caught’, being held, being supported in some way. It takes a long time and lots of work and an awful lot of support to eventually arrive at gratitude – we sure can’t get there alone.
It’s interesting to me how these two heartfelt perspectives come from the same place yet from different vantage points. Bernie says, “if you are in the gutter I’ll stand by your side until you get out and I’ll protect you and keep you from going there ever again” and Hillary says “here’s a proven way out; trust me. It works.” Either way, hear me roar.
For me, I was born tuned into injustice; and have always been moved by the rallying cries to help those without. I have to work very hard at gratitude, and it took years to arrive here, but I couldn’t have gotten here at all without people fighting for me. Rallying cries so loud and for so long, that I could no longer ignore them. All the loud voices that stood up for me, helped me find my way toward gratitude.
I believe that Hillary, like Bernie, fights for the underdog and for the rights of all those marginalized; but she isn’t connecting with them as much. Perhaps it’s because she’s counting blessings, but missing the fact that many people just can’t see them, yet.
Either way, I was proud of that town hall discussion. Of the questions New Hampshire asked. Of how much we all are listening, showing up, shaking hands, and trying. I’m really moved by Bernie, and stirred to action and belief. I’m a true believer in the merits of giant leaps and revolution. But here this: I’m grateful for them both.